
Financial technology, including the use of alternative data to generate credit scores, has enabled many underserved customers around the world to access financial services for the first time.
But to ensure that women benefit, governments, financial service providers, and the development community must consider “what data are being collected and how those data [falling] … along gender lines could unintentionally or intentionally have an impact on women’s access to credit,” said Sonja Kelly, global lead for research at Women’s World Banking, a nonprofit focused on financial inclusion for women.
Women are more likely than men to lack credit history information. They are also less likely to own mobile phones or smartphones, meaning they might not see as much benefit from alternative credit scoring algorithms that rely on these devices. The mobile gender gap is just one example of how women could have either the most to gain or the most to lose as digital tools open up new opportunities for access to credit.
While the COVID-19 pandemic has accelerated the use of digital financial services, experts told Devex that advancements in financial technology will not yield the same benefits for women as they do for men without intentionality — and partnership — between financial service providers and the global development community.
Loan officers tend to offer women smaller loans and penalize them more for mistakes, she said. But biases can also emerge in the data used to create algorithms for innovative lending methodologies. For example, a woman who has more unpaid care responsibilities may be less likely to spend time on a smartphone, as Women’s World Banking said in a recent report on algorithmic bias, financial inclusion, and gender.
With support from data.org’s Inclusive Growth and Recovery Challenge, Women’s World Banking is working to increase credit availability for low-income female entrepreneurs.
As part of that effort, it’s partnering with Lendingkart, a fintech startup based in Ahmedabad, India, with a focus on providing working capital loans for entrepreneurs to increase representation in the data pipeline and ensure that algorithms are fair to women applicants.
Women have high repayment rates relative to men, so with the right policies in place, they may in fact get bigger loans, or institutions could take more risks with women borrowers in their portfolios, Kelly said.
A ‘big missed opportunity’ for financial inclusion
When governments introduced social assistance payments in response to COVID-19, some prioritized speed over inclusion, said Helen Gradstein, a financial sector specialist with the World Bank Group’s Finance,
Competitiveness & Innovation Global Practice.
A number of countries missed the chance to financially include women within their pandemic payment programs, she said, describing this as a “big missed opportunity” during a recent event on the role of data in driving women’s financial inclusion.
Reducing the gender gap in financial inclusion requires systematically mainstreaming gender across all aspects of financial inclusion — such as by gathering the right data, ensuring women are included in leadership roles, and designing and measuring the impact of reforms, Gradstein said.
As more governments send digital payments and cash transfers directly to people, donors, international organizations, and multilateral development banks are exploring how to ensure that women have safe and equal access.
(Devex)
