
More women on boards and in senior management means higher levels of corporate social responsibility, academic studies have shown. Investors pushing companies to improve on environmental, social and governance issues might do well, then, to focus particularly on gender diversity. One study by Catalyst, a global non-profit organisation working to build better workplaces for women, and Harvard Business School, published in 2011, used charitable donations by US companies as a yardstick for corporate social responsibility.
It found companies with more women directors and corporate officers were significantly more generous. In 2007, Fortune 500 companies with no women directors made average donations of $969,000, while those with three or more women on the board gave $27.1m. Moreover, between 1997 and 2007, annual donations increased by $2.3m for each additional female board member. Even controlling for other factors, such as company size, financial performance and industry: “More women leaders correlates with higher levels of philanthropy,” says Allyson Zimmermann, head of Europe for Catalyst. Correlation is not causation, but other studies, for example, a meta-analysis by Kris Byron of Georgia State University published in 2014, support the likelihood of a better gender balance leading to enhanced social responsibility, rather than committed companies attracting more women to their boards.
Firms must advance beyond tokenism to remain competitive across a broad range of CSR practices Study by Utah State University Another study by Christy Glass and Alison Cook of Utah State University, published in November, found that even adding one or two women to previously all-male boards is associated with better community engagement, stronger governance and more sustainable environmental practices. However, the analysis also found that the more women on the board, the stronger a company’s commitment to corporate social responsibility, suggesting “firms must advance beyond tokenism to remain competitive across a broad range of CSR practices”.
Female board representation has increased markedly, pushed by the imposition of quotas in several countries, and by softer initiatives in others. In France, Iceland and Norway, where quotas apply, female representation on boards is above 40 per cent for the largest listed companies. The UK and US have not pursued quotas, and are at 29.8 per cent (FTSE 100) and 22 per cent (S&P 500).
Recommended Equality in workplace Women’s struggle to gain altitude in aviation industry It may be coincidence, but it is notable that socially responsible investing has grown similarly in recent years. According to Pictet Asset Management’s secular outlook, investment approaches that consider ESG will account for more than half of global assets under management by the end of the year. The walk may not always match the talk, but even if only lip service is being paid, it puts pressure on companies to improve their social responsibility scores. “Companies will need to embrace ESG to attract customers and investors in the new, sustainability-conscious world,” says Pictet.
Given the correlation between more female directors and improved social responsibility, there is an unarguable case for investors, companies and other parties to work hard at boosting female representation. Investors are becoming more active, having neglected the issue for years. In the UK, the requirement for companies to report their gender pay gap has put the issue in the spotlight and it falls to asset managers to hold boards responsible for progress. Some are pledging to be more robust in their voting.
For example, Legal & General Investment Management this year plans to vote against board chairs at FTSE 350 companies with less than 25 per cent female representation at board level. It will also vote against all-male boards in the Russell 3000 in the US. The Church Investors Group, an £18bn coalition, similarly plans to vote against nomination committee chairs at companies where women account for less than a third of board members. Investors clearly need to put their houses in order first. That may limit for a while the ability of some fund managers. To be taken seriously, gender diversity must be at or near the top of any manager’s ESG list.
Source:Financial Times
